Welcome to Issue #73 of Inside Scuba

In Issue #73 of Inside Scuba, we wrap up our two-part look at the business behind the "dream job" of diving, with Part 2 of The Price of Paradise. For the photographers, Byron shows how to place your strobes for sharper, more deliberate macro shots, and Alex Mustard and Matthew Sullivan ask whether subject-detect autofocus deserves a place underwater. We also watch the SS United States go down off Florida's Gulf Coast to become the world's largest artificial reef.

If you like these newsletters, please consider sharing them with friends who might also enjoy them.

What’s happening in this edition?

The Price of Paradise: Rethinking the Business of Diving (Part 2)

By Ciara Michaud

This article is Part 2 of a two-part series. Read Part 1 here.

Recap: In Part 1, we looked at sexual harassment and accountability in diving, the unseen workload behind the "dream job," and the expectation that dive professionals should simply be grateful for the work. In Part 2, we pick up with the complicated role of gratuities, then turn to safety, the realities of running a dive business, and what it would take to build a profession people can stay in.

The Complicated Role of Gratuities

In the United States, tipping is an established part of many dive operations, although expectations vary considerably around the world. Guests often enjoy recognizing exceptional service, and gratuities can make a meaningful difference in a dive professional's earnings. I've always appreciated travelers who acknowledge the effort involved in creating a memorable experience. However, concerns arise when tips shift from being an expression of appreciation to an expected component of someone's basic compensation.

Unlike wages, gratuities are unpredictable. A crew member might provide the same level of service on two consecutive days and receive dramatically different amounts. When professionals depend on tips to supplement modest wages, their financial stability becomes increasingly tied to factors beyond their control, including guest expectations, charter occupancy, and individual tipping habits.

Tip pooling introduces another layer of complexity. A successful charter relies on the collective efforts of captains, instructors, Divemasters, and boat crews, and sharing gratuities can be a reasonable way to recognize those contributions. However, I question the fairness of distributing tips earned through dive charters to retail or administrative employees who weren't directly involved in delivering the experience. Their work is valuable and deserves appropriate compensation, but should that compensation come from gratuities guests intended for the professionals responsible for their experience on the water?

In each issue of our newsletter, we will curate some top dive news from around the world. Links to each of the original articles are available.

❝

Safety & Incidents

DIVE Magazine: "British diver dies after being found unconscious at Zenobia wreck. A 61-year-old British diver was found unconscious at about 30 m (98 ft) on a dive off Larnaca, Cyprus, on November 10. He was taken to Larnaca General Hospital and pronounced dead; police are investigating and a post-mortem has been ordered."

Divernet: "Diver dies after medical emergency off Australia's Sunshine Coast. A 46-year-old certified diver signalled to end her dive shortly after starting off Point Cartwright, Queensland, on November 8, then suffered a medical episode at the surface and was pulled unconscious onto the dive boat. She died at the scene, and police are investigating and asking the public to watch for her missing mask and regulator."

Divernet: "Red Sea liveaboard catches fire in Hurghada. The liveaboard Unity burned while moored off the Hurghada Corniche on the evening of November 7, and the operator says everyone is safe. Reports of loud explosions led to speculation about diving cylinders, which is unconfirmed."

The Scuba News: "Nine UK Diving Fatalities Recorded as BSAC Report Highlights Decompression and Drysuit Risks. The report records 220 UK incidents plus 85 overseas, and nine divers died in UK incidents. Three of those deaths involved rebreather dives deeper than 50 m. It also records 53 decompression illness incidents and new findings on drysuit safety."

Marine Science

PetaPixel: "Canon technology used for world's first coral 'pregnancy test.' Coral Spawning International and Canon scanned six species of living coral underwater with a hospital ultrasound system and identified developing egg structures. The 'world first' claim is Canon's."

Mongabay: "Killing a dangerous coral. A Brazilian biologist and a team of volunteer divers are removing invasive sun coral by hand from an offshore oil platform to protect a marine protected area off Ipanema beach. The coral has no natural predators in the region and has spread along the coast."

Gear

Garmin (PR Newswire): "Garmin introduces the Descent X10 dive computer. Priced at $349.99, it has a backlit 2.1-inch display and a rental mode that lets dive schools reset it between customers. Battery life is rated at up to 50 hours in dive mode. A simulator in the Garmin Dive app lets new divers practice full dives before getting in the water."

X-Ray Magazine: "SCUBAPRO introduces the Aladin 100 dive computer. The new entry-level wrist computer is aimed at beginner and recreational divers, with a large backlit display, two-button operation and nitrox up to 50 percent. It is single-gas, transfers dive logs by Bluetooth to SCUBAPRO's LogTRAK 2.0 app, and has no air integration or built-in compass. Scubapro's DEMA launch price is £219 / €249 / US$299, and it is also pitched at dive schools and rental fleets."

Dive Travel & Destinations

DIVE Magazine: "SS United States becomes world's largest artificial reef. The 990 ft (302 m) liner was sunk off Destin, Florida, a day ahead of schedule because of approaching bad weather. It survived a last-minute legal challenge from the SS United States Preservation Foundation before going down."

Wrecks & Underwater Archaeology

Divernet: "New 3D survey of 'Little Pearl Harbour' WW2 shipwreck. A remote-sensing survey carried out on October 20-22 produced an updated 3D model and virtual reality content for the US Liberty ship Samuel J Tilden, which sank in the December 1943 air raid on Bari. The wreck lies at depths of up to 55 m, about 3 km from the city's main harbour in the southern Adriatic."

Conservation & Community

Mongabay: "US renews push to open Pacific marine protected area to fishing. NOAA Fisheries published proposed rules on November 9 that would allow commercial fishing around Johnston Atoll, Wake Island and Jarvis Island in the Pacific Islands Heritage Marine National Monument. The affected area is more than double the size of California, and the rules are open for public comment."

DeeperBlue: "Ewan McGregor calls for better protection of Scottish waters. The actor, a Blue Marine Foundation ambassador, appears in a video backing stronger seabed protections as the Scottish government consults on fishing management in inshore marine protected areas. The consultation covers 76 existing protected areas and 90 proposed management areas."

Divernet: "Aqaba scuba pioneer Rod Abbotson dies. The British diver, born in Liverpool in 1956, helped develop recreational and technical diving in Aqaba, Jordan, and co-founded the Dive Aqaba centre in 2002. He was 70."

Photo Competitions

GlobeNewswire (DIVEVOLK): "DIVEVOLK returns as Mobile Photography sponsor of Underwater Photo Awards 2026–2027. It is supplying three SeaTouch 4 Max Plus housing sets for the top smartphone entries, and free entries close January 2, 2027."

How to Position Strobes for Underwater Macro Photography

By Byron Conroy

Most underwater photographers are happy as long as the subject has some light on it. Point the strobes roughly forward, fire, and hope for the best. It works, in the sense that you get an exposed image. But it rarely produces a great one.

Strobe positioning for underwater macro photography is a completely different discipline from wide angle. In wide angle, we are trying to spread light out wide, far and evenly across a big scene. In macro, the subject is small, the working distance is short, and you have control over almost every variable, both the ambient light and the strobe light. That makes macro much closer to studio photography than anything else we do underwater. You get to decide exactly where the light falls, where the shadows sit and how much of the background you show.

This article walks through how I position my strobes for macro, from the setup I start every dive with to more advanced techniques like turning one strobe off and inward lighting. If you have already read my piece on strobe positioning for wide angle, think of this as its companion. The thinking is the same. The goal is precision.

Two Strobes and Beam Restrictors, Not Diffusers

I shoot all of my macro with two Retra Flash Pro Max II strobes. People sometimes ask whether one strobe is enough for macro, and it can be, but two gives you far more options. Two strobes let you shape the light, build shadows and create contrast in ways one strobe simply can't. And if you want a single, aggressive light source, you can always switch one off. You can't switch on a strobe you didn't bring.

The bigger change for most people is what goes on the front of the strobe. In wide angle we use diffusers to spread the light and soften it. In macro I almost never use a diffuser. What matters far more is a beam restrictor. On my Retras I use Retra's Super Macro ring, which fits onto the Reduction ring and narrows the beam considerably.

The reason is control. In macro we want a clean, defined edge to the light, so we can be very deliberate about exactly where it lands on the subject and, just as importantly, where it doesn't. A narrow beam keeps light off the sand, the reef and the particles in the water, and puts it only where you want it. Once you start shooting with a restricted beam, flooding the frame with wide light starts to feel very clumsy.

A Retra Pro Max with beam restrictors alongside one without

Subject-Detect Autofocus Underwater: When to Trust It and When to Switch It Off

By Alex Mustard and Matthew Sullivan

In this article from The Underwater Photography Show, we'll be diving into subject-detect autofocus modes on modern mirrorless cameras, how they actually work underwater, and when to rely on them or turn them off.

A Fish-Detect Camera Raises a Bigger Question

Nikon has just announced the Z5IIC, and it is the first camera ever to offer fish-detect autofocus, which sounds appealing to underwater photographers. It also raises a broader question: how useful are subject-detect modes underwater at all? Most are designed for topside shooters, which is why cameras offer insect, bird, mammal, and even train and car modes. Many of them can work underwater too. So when should you use them, when should you avoid them, how do they compare to older autofocus systems, and are you at a disadvantage if your camera doesn't have them?

Tools, Not Rules

I'll (Alex) give my answer up front. Autofocus (AF), and every mode, pattern and tool incorporated into it, exists to help us as photographers. So if a mode isn't helpful for you and what you shoot, don't use it. If a mode IS helping you, use it, even if all your friends say they hate it. The reason cameras have all these options is that one size does not fit all. Subjects are different, cameras are different, lenses are different, conditions are different and photographers are different.

It's also worth noting that AF tools often share names across camera systems without necessarily behaving the same way. The processing power in different cameras can make a huge difference to how they perform. The same feature can be brilliant on one body and a waste of time on another.

Where and what you shoot matters just as much. Modern mirrorless AF works using the full sensor data. Underwater, that data quickly becomes fairly monochrome because of the ambient light at depth. When you dive shallow, in clear water, the sensor gets a lovely, clean view, so the advanced modes work well. Dive in dark, dingy, sediment-filled conditions and the fancy AF modes tail off much faster and become less reliable. On the other hand, if you shoot macro in dark temperate water but use a focus light, the camera sensor now has a great view and all the fancy modes work very well again.

Pink anemonefish peering out from a pale anemone

Our Video of the Week is a first-hand look at the sinking of the SS United States, the nearly 1,000-foot ocean liner Okaloosa County, Florida, sent to the bottom about 22 nautical miles southwest of Destin to create the world's largest artificial reef. Weather moved the sinking up to Wednesday, Veterans Day. The plan puts the ship at roughly 180 feet with its top decks about 60 feet below the surface, which should suit novice and experienced divers alike. This clip from The Scuba Diving Channel puts you right in the middle of it. Check it out.

Summary

Thanks for spending a little time with us, and we hope this edition gave you something to chew on, whether that's a new strobe angle or a new dive site. If you enjoyed it, please share it with a dive buddy or two. Until next time, stay safe, keep exploring, and happy bubbles!

Andy & Byron

Reply

Avatar

or to participate