In this article from The Underwater Photography Show, we'll be diving into subject-detect autofocus modes on modern mirrorless cameras, how they actually work underwater, and when to rely on them or turn them off.
A Fish-Detect Camera Raises a Bigger Question
Nikon has just announced the Z5IIC, and it is the first camera ever to offer fish-detect autofocus, which sounds appealing to underwater photographers. It also raises a broader question: how useful are subject-detect modes underwater at all? Most are designed for topside shooters, which is why cameras offer insect, bird, mammal, and even train and car modes. Many of them can work underwater too. So when should you use them, when should you avoid them, how do they compare to older autofocus systems, and are you at a disadvantage if your camera doesn't have them?
Tools, Not Rules
I'll (Alex) give my answer up front. Autofocus (AF), and every mode, pattern and tool incorporated into it, exists to help us as photographers. So if a mode isn't helpful for you and what you shoot, don't use it. If a mode IS helping you, use it, even if all your friends say they hate it. The reason cameras have all these options is that one size does not fit all. Subjects are different, cameras are different, lenses are different, conditions are different and photographers are different.
It's also worth noting that AF tools often share names across camera systems without necessarily behaving the same way. The processing power in different cameras can make a huge difference to how they perform. The same feature can be brilliant on one body and a waste of time on another.
Where and what you shoot matters just as much. Modern mirrorless AF works using the full sensor data. Underwater, that data quickly becomes fairly monochrome because of the ambient light at depth. When you dive shallow, in clear water, the sensor gets a lovely, clean view, so the advanced modes work well. Dive in dark, dingy, sediment-filled conditions and the fancy AF modes tail off much faster and become less reliable. On the other hand, if you shoot macro in dark temperate water but use a focus light, the camera sensor now has a great view and all the fancy modes work very well again.

Put together, photographer preference, camera capability, and environment all shape how well a mode performs. So if I tell you a mode is brilliant, that may not be true for you. And the mode you love may not be best for me. That said, we will cover some of the modes that we find genuinely helpful in making it easier to get the shot.
When Eye Detection Doesn't Make the Jump
I (Matthew) usually keep my Nikon Z9 in animal detect, and it does a great job. The one subject it has always struggled with is my dog, Nai'a. She's a black-and-white Dalmatian with spots everywhere and dark eyes. Every camera I've used, including the Sony A9 III, has failed to find her eyes. I recently got my hands on a Sony A7R VI and have taken around 300 pictures of her. Every single one is locked perfectly on her eye.
I was excited to take it underwater, so I left it in the same animal eye-detect mode. Across three fairly mediocre dives, I couldn't get the tracking to follow an eye or get eye autofocus to activate at all. Conditions here have been very bad, with heavy rain dropping visibility to a couple of feet and a lot of material in the water. I wondered whether all that debris was confusing the tracking or making it front-focus?

How to Make Subject Detection Work for You
I (Alex) think the key is understanding what these modes are doing. Each one draws on a bank of images the camera has been programmed with to represent that type of subject. The more specific the mode, the more specific those images are. Eventually we may see individual dog-breed modes, because it's only a matter of loading the software with pictures of each breed!
The new Nikon Z5IIC will have been loaded with a bank of fish pictures. But did they include strange-looking fish? What about a flounder, a seahorse or a sea dragon? It will certainly work well with a tuna and a goldfish, while a butterflyfish with fake eye spots could throw it completely. The camera has done a finite amount of learning, and it applies that learning to whatever you point it at.

On the debris question: crud and distractions usually aren't much of a problem for these modes. One advantage of subject recognition is that once it has locked on, a blob of detritus or a strand of kelp can drift across the frame and the camera knows it's a distraction and holds focus on the subject. The bigger issue is the overall image quality that the sensor is getting. Dark, shady, monochromatic conditions are where these modes struggle, and poor visibility also lowers ambient light, which makes it harder still for the sensor.
When the camera can't recognise what it's seeing, either because the conditions don't let it work out the scene or because you've set too narrow a subject category, it gets confused. It will either lock onto the wrong thing or lock onto nothing at all.
Understand What You Are Asking the Camera to Do
On my Sony A7R VI, the mode I use most (so far) is the combined animal/bird setting, because it gives the camera a wider range of targets. I suspect the A7R VI works so well with Matthew's dog Nai'a because its Animal mode is well tuned to her, with plenty of dog and cat pictures behind it. It would probably struggle much more with an unusual-looking mammal like a duck-billed platypus.

Nikon users have told me that bird tracking works very well for blackwater photography. Blackwater animals don't look like birds, but they move around the frame very similarly to the way a whole bird would against the sky. A small speck moving across a black background looks to the camera like a bird in flight, and "bird-in-flight" tracking handles that well. An AF mode tuned to "bird-on-a-stick", where the goal is to find the eye and focus on it, wouldn't work so well.
Keep a Get-Out-of-Jail-Free Card
I use subject detection focus modes a lot when shooting macro and portrait images, but I always make sure I can quickly deactivate (and reactivate) this mode. On my Sony housing, I set the record button, a big lever right by my thumb, to toggle subject detection on and off. So when subject detection gets confused, such as the AF landing on the nostril of a moray eel or the eye spot of a butterflyfish, I can cancel it immediately, without taking my eye from the viewfinder. The same goes for shooting a frogfish on a sponge when the camera decides one of the sponge's large openings looks like an eye. One press (of my record lever) and the autofocus drops back to a "non-thinking" AF mode. I am saying to the camera, just focus where the point is, then keep tracking whatever you lock onto there. Then when I move on to the next subject I will reactivate subject detection with a tap of the same lever.

Trust It, or Take Control Back
I (Matthew) find it hard to trust these systems and end up fighting with them. When the A9 III came out, its autofocus was hailed as the most advanced in any camera, and at first I didn't think it was that good. Then one day I forced myself not to override what the camera was doing, and I realised it was probably getting it right. Half the problem is my own stubbornness. I've done the same thing recently with the A7R VI and the A7 V, trying to impose my will on them instead of letting them do their job.
I (Alex) would add that if you want to be in control, then take it back. You don't get the best pictures by using the most gadgets. You get them by choosing the gadgets that work for YOU, at that moment, as a photographer. If subject detection frees you to think about other things, it's the ideal mode for you. If you spend the whole dive overthinking it and fighting it, you'll miss shots out of frustration, and you'll stop thinking about composition and lighting because you're fixated on that one thing. So it isn't right for you.
For some photographers an even simpler approach works better, such as using manual focus with focus peaking (or DMF on a Sony). The different modes exist because they suit different subjects and, perhaps more importantly, different users. That's why I'd never make a click-magnet video titled "the two autofocus modes you should be using and the one you should definitely avoid." If an AF mode I love and have taken lovely pictures with doesn't work for you, it isn't the right mode for you.
But before you bin these features, take time to understand the modes and how they work, because this is a big part of getting the most from them. On a recent trip to Lembeh, my good friend Mehmet, who has stuck with his Nikon D850 for years and taken plenty of teasing for it, finally tried a new Sony A7R VI for macro. By the end of the first day he came up to me and said "this camera is like cheating!" He was able to adapt to the very different AF modes instantly and saw the advantages.
Give a New Mode a Fair Trial
If you're struggling with autofocus, we do recommend that you try some of the approaches that have worked for us, but don't judge a mode after two minutes on a poor dive where nothing is happening. If you have a week of diving booked, commit to a mode for a day or two. If it's a big change from what you're used to, you probably won't like it on the first dive. By dive three, four, five or six, you'll likely find it's getting you shots you weren't getting before. You'll be fussing less and thinking more about composition, lighting, your background, and the small changes in position that transform the look of a shot. But also remember that Matthew and I have different preferences — so you are not wrong if you decide not to follow our advice.

That's the real power of these modes: they make autofocusing easier. But if they're not making it easier for you, with the camera you have and the subjects you shoot, then don't use them!
Catch the full conversation in the video below.


