This article is Part 2 of a two-part series. Read Part 1 here.
Recap: In Part 1, we looked at sexual harassment and accountability in diving, the unseen workload behind the "dream job," and the expectation that dive professionals should simply be grateful for the work. In Part 2, we pick up with the complicated role of gratuities, then turn to safety, the realities of running a dive business, and what it would take to build a profession people can stay in.
The Complicated Role of Gratuities
In the United States, tipping is an established part of many dive operations, although expectations vary considerably around the world. Guests often enjoy recognizing exceptional service, and gratuities can make a meaningful difference in a dive professional's earnings. I've always appreciated travelers who acknowledge the effort involved in creating a memorable experience. However, concerns arise when tips shift from being an expression of appreciation to an expected component of someone's basic compensation.
Unlike wages, gratuities are unpredictable. A crew member might provide the same level of service on two consecutive days and receive dramatically different amounts. When professionals depend on tips to supplement modest wages, their financial stability becomes increasingly tied to factors beyond their control, including guest expectations, charter occupancy, and individual tipping habits.
Tip pooling introduces another layer of complexity. A successful charter relies on the collective efforts of captains, instructors, Divemasters, and boat crews, and sharing gratuities can be a reasonable way to recognize those contributions. However, I question the fairness of distributing tips earned through dive charters to retail or administrative employees who weren't directly involved in delivering the experience. Their work is valuable and deserves appropriate compensation, but should that compensation come from gratuities guests intended for the professionals responsible for their experience on the water?

Management participation raises even greater concerns. Federal law generally prohibits managers and supervisors from receiving employees' pooled tips, although certain arrangements involving other employees may be permissible. Beyond legal compliance, businesses have an ethical responsibility to ensure their gratuity practices are transparent and equitable. Employees should understand how tips are distributed, and guests should feel confident that their appreciation reaches the professionals they intended to recognize.
The broader concern is whether some dive operations have become overly reliant on gratuities to supplement wages rather than establishing compensation structures that adequately reflect the responsibilities of the job. Financial pressures should never influence professional judgment, particularly in an industry where safety must take precedence over customer satisfaction. Instructors, Divemasters, and captains need to feel comfortable making conservative decisions, declining inappropriate requests, and establishing boundaries without worrying about how those decisions might affect their tips.
Gratuities can be a meaningful way to acknowledge exceptional service, but they should not determine whether a professional can afford to remain in the industry. A sustainable compensation model should recognize the value of professional expertise and responsibility, with tips serving as appreciation rather than a substitute for fair wages.
When Working Conditions Become a Safety Issue
The conversation about working conditions becomes even more important when we consider the physical demands and safety responsibilities of professional diving. Preparing equipment, lifting cylinders, climbing ladders, assisting guests, managing changing ocean conditions, and completing multiple dives require endurance and concentration.
Instructors and Divemasters must remain alert to developing problems and be prepared to respond to emergencies. A 2024 study examining occupational health among 423 male scuba instructors in India's Andaman and Nicobar Islands reported that 10.4% of participants had experienced a physical injury underwater. The study reflects a specific population and should not be interpreted as a global injury rate, but it highlights the importance of understanding occupational risks. [2]
The physical demands of diving become particularly relevant when considering fatigue, illness, and recovery time. Dive operations often work within narrow scheduling windows. Weather changes, last-minute reservations, equipment problems, and unexpected absences can quickly disrupt the day, particularly when specific professional qualifications are required.

Those operational challenges are legitimate. Anyone who has managed a business or organized dive activities understands how difficult last-minute changes can be. However, a professional who is exhausted, ill, or otherwise unfit to work may not be in the best position to meet the physical and cognitive demands of the job.
Congestion, for example, can affect someone's ability to equalize safely, while fatigue can affect concentration and decision-making. The expectation that professionals exercise conservative judgment about their own fitness to dive should be supported by the environments in which they work.
Staffing plans, reasonable scheduling, appropriate recovery time, and clear procedures for unexpected absences are therefore more than administrative concerns. They are elements of responsible risk management.
Healthcare and income protection are also part of this discussion. Many dive professionals work seasonally, part-time, or independently, and may have limited access to employer-sponsored benefits. Professional liability insurance doesn't necessarily cover personal medical expenses or replace income lost because of an injury.
For someone whose livelihood depends on being physically capable of diving, an extended absence can create serious financial difficulties. An operation benefits from professionals who are physically prepared, attentive, and confident in their ability to make sound decisions. Customers benefit from the same thing.
Taking care of the people responsible for safety is part of taking safety seriously.
The Other Side of the Equation: Running a Dive Business
Discussions about compensation and workplace expectations are incomplete without considering the financial realities facing dive operators. Running a dive business is expensive, and the costs are often less visible than the prices customers pay.
Boats require fuel, maintenance, insurance, permits, and qualified crews. Compressors need servicing, cylinders require inspections, rental equipment wears out, and facilities come with ongoing overhead. Weather cancellations can eliminate revenue while many expenses remain unchanged. Seasonal demand, fluctuating reservations, and unexpected repairs create additional uncertainty.

Operating in Hawaiʻi introduces its own logistical challenges, particularly when equipment and replacement parts must be shipped across the Pacific. A full boat doesn't necessarily mean a profitable charter, and many small business owners contribute substantial unpaid time to maintaining their operations.
Some have invested their savings, taken on debt, or assumed considerable personal financial risk to build the businesses their employees and customers depend on. These realities deserve recognition. Improving compensation isn't simply a matter of redistributing money that may not exist.
At the same time, financial pressure doesn't eliminate an operator's responsibility to establish appropriate employment practices, maintain safe working conditions, and comply with applicable laws. Financial pressures may complicate decisions about staffing and compensation, but they do not diminish an employer's responsibility to address misconduct and treat employees with dignity.
A healthy business model should be capable of meeting its obligations, compensating people appropriately, maintaining equipment and infrastructure, and investing in its future. Reaching that point may require difficult decisions about pricing, staffing, operating efficiency, and the services offered.
Customers are part of this equation. A two-tank charter represents considerably more than a boat ride and access to compressed air. The price reflects professional expertise, vessel maintenance, equipment, insurance, safety systems, permits, and the infrastructure required to operate responsibly.
The same applies to training, where quality instruction requires preparation, supervision, maintained equipment, facilities, and sufficient time for students to develop competence.
Price competition is a normal part of business, and affordability matters. Making diving accessible to more people is a worthwhile objective. However, an industry that competes primarily on price risks creating pressure to reduce costs in areas that directly influence service quality, compensation, and operational resilience.
That doesn't mean every operator should automatically charge more. Different destinations, customer markets, and business models have different financial realities, and some businesses operate efficiently enough to provide excellent experiences at competitive prices.
As someone who operates a dive business, I recognize that responsible financial management is part of providing a good experience, not separate from it. Sustainable pricing allows businesses to invest in qualified people, maintain appropriate standards, and continue serving customers over the long term.
The goal shouldn't be to position employees and operators on opposing sides of the discussion. Both have legitimate financial needs, and the long-term health of the industry depends on finding business models capable of supporting them.
Building a Profession People Can Stay In
The diving industry is remarkably diverse. A small independent instructor, a family-owned dive center, a large resort operation, and an international liveaboard company may all operate under very different financial and logistical conditions. There's no single employment model that will suit every business or professional.
Traditional employment can offer consistent work, mentorship, established facilities, and organizational support. Independent instruction offers flexibility and autonomy, along with the responsibility of managing marketing, insurance, scheduling, equipment, and financial risk. Both models can provide meaningful careers when expectations and responsibilities are clearly understood.
For established operators, improving working conditions may involve reviewing compensation arrangements, making schedules more predictable, creating opportunities for advancement, and providing benefits where financially feasible. Transparency is particularly valuable. Professionals should understand how they're paid, how gratuities are distributed, what responsibilities are expected, and what opportunities exist to develop their careers.
Independent instructors and established dive centers may also find opportunities to collaborate. An instructor who brings their own students can benefit from access to vessels, facilities, equipment, and logistical support, while the operator gains additional business. These arrangements require clear agreements, appropriate insurance, fair pricing, and compliance with applicable employment laws.

Professional development should also extend beyond diving skills. Being an excellent instructor doesn't automatically prepare someone to manage payroll, navigate employment regulations, resolve workplace conflicts, or lead a team. Many dive businesses begin with someone who is passionate about the ocean and exceptionally skilled at teaching others to explore it.
Supporting those individuals as they develop business and leadership skills could strengthen the industry considerably. Likewise, becoming a more senior dive professional should involve more than accumulating certifications and experience. Mentorship, ethical judgment, communication, and the ability to establish a respectful professional environment deserve continued attention throughout someone's career.
Better information would help, too. Comprehensive research into compensation, actual working hours, benefits, professional expenses, occupational injuries, and career longevity could provide a clearer picture of the challenges facing dive professionals.
Understanding the operating costs and financial pressures of dive businesses is equally important. Broader evidence would help us identify which challenges are widespread, which vary by location or business model, and where meaningful improvements are possible.
The industry doesn't need every operation to look the same. We do, however, need professional standards and workplace expectations that reflect the responsibilities people assume when they choose to work in diving.
A Future Worth Investing In
Diving has given me an extraordinary amount, both personally and professionally. I've met remarkable people, traveled to places I once only dreamed of visiting, and had the opportunity to help others discover a world that continues to fascinate me after thousands of dives.
My appreciation for this profession is precisely why I believe these conversations matter.
I've seen businesses that invest in their employees, cultivate exceptional teams, and create environments where professionals are respected and supported. I've also seen practices that deserve closer examination. Both experiences have influenced how I think about the industry's future.
I don't believe the challenges facing diving can be reduced to a simple division between employees and business owners. Most professionals enter this industry because they genuinely care about what they do, and many operators have made enormous sacrifices to create opportunities for others to enjoy the ocean.
Recognizing those realities doesn't mean overlooking inappropriate conduct, inadequate compensation, or working conditions that deserve improvement. Nor should raising these concerns be interpreted as a lack of appreciation for the opportunities this profession provides. Caring about an industry means being willing to examine its shortcomings, particularly when those shortcomings affect the people responsible for its success.
The people coming forward with their experiences have helped bring difficult issues into public view. What happens next shouldn't depend solely on whether those conversations continue to attract attention on social media. The more lasting question is what we're willing to learn from them.
We have spent decades learning how to become better stewards of the ocean. We've improved our training, refined our safety practices, and challenged ourselves to think more carefully about the impact we leave behind.
Perhaps it's time to bring that same commitment to the way we treat one another.
The future of diving cannot be measured solely by the health of our oceans or the success of our businesses. We must also consider the safety, dignity, and well-being of the people who make this industry possible.
References
[2] Vincent, V., Ramakrishnan, K., Singh, S., & Shanmugam, J. (2024). Determinants of Morbidities and Occupational Hazards among Scuba Divers in Andaman and Nicobar Islands, India. Journal of Pharmacy & Bioallied Sciences, 16(Suppl 4), S3113–S3115. https://doi.org/10.4103/jpbs.jpbs_503_24
Additional reading: Divers Alert Network. Research Reports and Diving Safety Resources. https://dan.org/research-reports/
Reference [1], the Business of Diving Institute survey, is cited in Part 1.

Ciara Michaud is an Army veteran, PADI Course Director, and founder of Seaira Dives based on Hawaiʻi Island. Passionate about education and adventure, she leads dive expeditions around the world, combining diver training with unforgettable wildlife encounters. Ciara enjoys helping divers build confidence, develop new skills, and discover a deeper appreciation for the underwater world.

