Most underwater photographers are happy as long as the subject has some light on it. Point the strobes roughly forward, fire, and hope for the best. It works, in the sense that you get an exposed image. But it rarely produces a great one.
Strobe positioning for underwater macro photography is a completely different discipline from wide angle. In wide angle, we are trying to spread light out wide, far and evenly across a big scene. In macro, the subject is small, the working distance is short, and you have control over almost every variable, both the ambient light and the strobe light. That makes macro much closer to studio photography than anything else we do underwater. You get to decide exactly where the light falls, where the shadows sit and how much of the background you show.
This article walks through how I position my strobes for macro, from the setup I start every dive with to more advanced techniques like turning one strobe off and inward lighting. If you have already read my piece on strobe positioning for wide angle, think of this as its companion. The thinking is the same. The goal is precision.
Two Strobes and Beam Restrictors, Not Diffusers
I shoot all of my macro with two Retra Flash Pro Max II strobes. People sometimes ask whether one strobe is enough for macro, and it can be, but two gives you far more options. Two strobes let you shape the light, build shadows and create contrast in ways one strobe simply can't. And if you want a single, aggressive light source, you can always switch one off. You can't switch on a strobe you didn't bring.
You might also wonder why I use such powerful strobes for macro, when a lot of people choose small, low powered strobes for close up work. The main reason is the lighting techniques I use. I shoot a lot of slow shutter speed images with ND filters, and an ND filter cuts a huge amount of light before it ever reaches the sensor. To light a subject properly through an ND filter, you need far more strobe power than you would otherwise. If you never shoot that way, smaller strobes can work well for macro. If you want the freedom to experiment, the extra power is worth having.
The bigger change for most people is what goes on the front of the strobe. In wide angle we use diffusers to spread the light and soften it. In macro I almost never use a diffuser. What matters far more is a beam restrictor. On my Retras I use Retra's Super Macro ring, which fits onto the Reduction ring and narrows the beam considerably.
The reason is control. In macro we want a clean, defined edge to the light, so we can be very deliberate about exactly where it lands on the subject and, just as importantly, where it doesn't. A narrow beam keeps light off the sand, the reef and the particles in the water, and puts it only where you want it. Once you start shooting with a restricted beam, flooding the frame with wide light starts to feel very clumsy.

A Retra Pro Max with beam restrictors alongside one without
My Starting Strobe Position for Macro
Every macro dive starts the same way for me. As soon as I get in the water, I place my strobes to the left and right of my macro port, angled slightly inward toward the port by around 20 to 30 degrees. At that angle, the two beams meet roughly 12 inches (30 cm) in front of the port, which is about where most of my subjects end up.
I start both strobes at about one third power. That gives me plenty of room to go up or down once I see the first test shot.
It is important to understand what this is. It is a starting point, not an answer. It gets me shooting quickly and gives me a known baseline, but I adjust it constantly through the dive, often for every single subject.
One of the most useful adjustments is also one of the most overlooked. All too often, people run both strobes at exactly the same power. Setting them to different powers is one of the simplest ways to add contrast to a macro image. You can do it by changing the power settings, or simply by moving one strobe closer to the subject than the other. Either way, one side of the image becomes brighter than the other, and the subject immediately gains shape and depth.

A standard position, notice how narrow the Baams are due to the restrictors
Ambient Light and Your Background, Blue or Black
Strobe positioning doesn't happen in isolation. As with all types of photography, the best lighting in the world is the lighting you can't see, and that means thinking about ambient light before you think about the strobes.
With macro, you have a clear choice to make. You can let ambient light into the background, or you can cut it out entirely. This is a distinct stylistic decision, and it should change how you light the subject.
When you let ambient light in, you get blue, natural looking backgrounds. A slower shutter speed and a wider aperture let more of the surrounding water register, and shooting upward toward open water helps. With an open, natural background like this, a more natural lighting style usually looks best. Gentle, balanced strobe light suits the softer mood. I go into this in much more detail in my article on mastering natural backgrounds in underwater macro photography.
When you cut the ambient light out, you get a black background. A fast shutter speed, a small aperture and a low ISO kill the ambient exposure, so the only light in the image is the light from your strobes. Black backgrounds reward contrast, detail and texture, and this is where more aggressive lighting styles really come into their own. Inward lighting in particular, which we will come to shortly, works beautifully against black.

Black blackgrounds work great with aggressive lighting that draws out texture and details
Simple Two Strobe Lighting
The first technique is the one most people already use, just done with more intention. Both strobes sit either side of the port in roughly the starting position, aimed so their beams meet on the subject. The result is clean, even light that shows color and detail clearly.
This is the right choice when the subject itself is the story. A brightly colored nudibranch, a shrimp on an anemone, or a fish portrait where you want every detail visible all suit simple two strobe lighting. It is also the style that sits most naturally with an open blue background.
The key is that even doesn't have to mean identical. Small changes make a big difference here. Pull one strobe back slightly, drop its power a stop, or angle it a little further away, and you introduce just enough shadow to give the subject form without losing that clean, well lit look. Check the edges of the subject after every test shot and adjust before moving on.

Simple light, but perfectly placed
Turning One Strobe Off
This is one of the most powerful techniques in macro lighting, and one of the least used. Switch one strobe off and you immediately create an image with a light side and a dark side.
That contrast does a lot of work. It gives the subject shape, it adds mood, and it pulls the eye straight to the lit side of the frame. A subject that looked flat and ordinary with two strobes can suddenly look dramatic with one.
Position the remaining strobe off to one side rather than straight above the port, so the light rakes across the subject and the shadow falls away on the other side. Think about which side of the subject you want to reveal and which you want to hide. With a narrow beam from a beam restrictor, you can keep the light off the background entirely, which makes this technique especially strong on a black background.
Once one strobe is off, you can also replace it with a completely different light source. For example, you might have your main strobe lighting the subject from the left, then use a colored light, such as a red light, coming in from behind the subject to create a rim of light around its edges. This is known as rim lighting. Combining a single strobe with a different type and color of light opens up a whole new set of creative possibilities for single strobe images.
It also teaches you something valuable. With only one light, every small movement of the strobe shows in the image, so you learn very quickly how light behaves on different subjects.

Turn a strobe off, add in additional light sources from other directions and with new colors
Inward Lighting
Inward lighting is where macro starts to feel like real studio work. Instead of keeping the strobes beside or behind the port, you move them forward, out in front of the port, and point them back toward each other, across the subject.
Because the light now comes from the sides and slightly from behind, it skims across the surface of the subject rather than hitting it head on. Edges light up, textures stand out, and the parts of the subject facing the camera fall into shadow. The result is a lot of contrast, a lot of detail, and strong highlights and shadows within the image.
This style is at its best against a black background. With the ambient light cut out, the rim of light around the subject separates it cleanly from the darkness behind. It is particularly effective on subjects with texture, translucency or interesting outlines.
With a black background, it is especially important not to throw spare light into the rest of the scene. When the ambient light is gone, anywhere your strobe light lands will show up in the image. Light that spills onto the sand in front of the subject, or onto the reef behind it, becomes a bright distraction and ruins the clean black you were working for. Aim your strobes so the light falls on the subject and nowhere else. This is exactly where beam restrictors earn their place.
Inward lighting takes some practice. Small changes in angle have a big effect, and with the strobes pointing back toward the camera you need to make sure the light is hitting the subject and not spilling into the port. Take a test shot, look closely at where the highlights are falling, and refine from there. Narrow beams from beam restrictors make this far easier to control.


Inward lighting can add drama, texture and details
Strobe Positioning With Wet Lenses
Wet lenses change your working distance, so they change where your strobes need to be. The good news is that the rules are simple.
With a Nauticam MFO-1, you don't need to change anything. My standard starting position works perfectly well.
With the MFO-3, the optic itself extends further out in front of the port, so I move my strobes slightly forward until they sit level with the front of the MFO-3. That keeps the light from being blocked and puts it back where the subject now is. I cover the optic itself in my Nauticam MFO-3 review.
With strong diopters like the Nauticam SMC-2 and SMC-3 (replacement for the SMC-1), things change completely. At this magnification, the area you are photographing is smaller than the camera's full frame sensor, and the subject is very close to the lens. The finer points of lighting matter much less here, because the whole scene is so small. The priority is simply getting light onto the subject. I push my strobes well forward and point them directly at the subject so the light reaches it at all.
Be prepared for how difficult this can be, especially with an SMC-3 or even an SMC-2. The working distance between the front of the diopter and the subject can be less than a tenth of an inch (just a couple of millimeters). At that distance, the diopter itself blocks much of the light. You need to wrap the light around the front of the diopter so that at least some of it reaches the front of the subject, rather than lighting only its sides or the scene around it.

Shooting with a Nauticam SMC 2 this subject is magnified so much it is hard to get light on it due to proximity to the lens
Taking It Further With Snoots
If beam restrictors narrow the light, snoots take that idea to its extreme. A snoot turns your strobe into a tight spotlight, letting you light just the eye of a frogfish or a single shrimp while everything else falls to black. It is the most precise lighting tool in macro photography.
Snoots deserve far more space than I can give them here, so rather than repeat myself, I'd point you to two pieces I have written on the subject. Whispering with Light looks at moving beyond traditional snoot photography, and my Backscatter OS-3 optical snoot review covers precision lighting on Lembeh's black sand.

Take things as far as you want with snoots
Manual Power, Always
TTL is a switch on my strobes that I would gladly not have. The only time my strobes are ever in TTL is by accident.
Everything in this article depends on control. Different powers on each strobe, a dark side and a light side, a rim of light against black. TTL works against all of that, because it tries to produce an average, safe exposure. Precision lighting needs you to decide exactly how much light each strobe delivers. Take complete manual control of your strobes at all times, and make every change yourself.

Special lighting makes special images
The Biggest Mistake in Macro Lighting
The most common mistake I see is treating every dive and every subject the same. Strobes go into one position at the start of the dive and stay there, at the same power, for every subject. Light gets thrown all over the scene, and as long as the subject is exposed, the photographer is happy.
But every subject is different. A reflective shrimp, a dark frogfish, a translucent nudibranch and a goby in a bottle all need different light. Macro gives you the chance to light each one precisely, the way a studio photographer would. It would be a shame to waste it.
On your next macro dive, give yourself one rule. For every subject, move at least one strobe or change at least one power setting before you take the final frame. Try one strobe off. Try different powers on each side. If the background is black, try bringing the strobes forward for inward lighting.
You'll take fewer photos, and you'll spend more time thinking before each one. But you will start to see light as something you place, not something you simply switch on. That is the moment macro photography stops being about getting light on the subject, and starts being about lighting it.

